Here’s a scenario that keeps estate lawyers up at night: a will gives a spouse a life interest in property, names who takes if the spouse dies first, and then simply stops. Nobody wrote down who gets the property when the spouse’s life interest ends.
That’s exactly what happened in Kentros v. Kentros, 2026 ONCA 546, released by the Court of Appeal on July 28, 2026. The Court upheld orders giving effect to what the testator clearly meant and unwinding a trustee’s attempt to take advantage of the gap, and was candid that the law on fixing wills after probate is still unsettled in Ontario.
What happened
Effie Kentros died in March 2017. She left her husband, Manthos, and their children, including a daughter with two children, Matteo and Sofia.
Shortly before her death, Effie signed a new will dealing with two properties in Fort Erie. It gave Manthos a life interest in both. If Manthos didn’t survive her by 30 days, the properties went to the grandchildren. But Manthos did survive her, and the will said nothing about where the properties went after his life interest ended. The drafting lawyer later admitted he had simply left out the remainderman clause.
Manthos, who was also the estate trustee, obtained a certificate of appointment. In 2019 he moved both properties into an alter ego trust he had set up, where he kept the power to revoke the trust and to sell or mortgage the properties. His position was that, with no gift over, the properties fell into the residue, and the residue was his.
The application judge disagreed. He found clear evidence that Effie wanted the grandchildren to have the properties whenever Manthos died, and ordered language added to the will to say so. A family member appealed, and other parties cross-appealed on the choice of remedy and on costs. The Court of Appeal (Sossin, Gomery and Osborne JJ.A.) dismissed both.
Fixing a will after probate: construction or rectification?
This is the part of Kentros lawyers will be talking about.
Ontario draws a line between a court of probate, which decides what document is the will, and a court of construction, which decides what a probated will means. Because Manthos already had a certificate of appointment and nobody was attacking it, the application judge was sitting as a court of construction.
How far a court of construction can go in adding or deleting words is a genuinely open question here. Some Ontario cases allow it; others insist the court’s role is interpretive only. The Court of Appeal acknowledged that lingering uncertainty, and the criticism it has drawn, but didn’t need to resolve it.
Instead, the Court found it could reach the same result by construing the will as written, without adding words to it. The presumption against intestacy did a lot of work: nothing in the will suggested Effie meant to leave anything undisposed of, and the gift to the grandchildren if Manthos died first could fairly be read as her plan for when his interest ended. The missing clause was a clear drafting mistake, and correcting it simply let the will say what she meant. (All About Estates; Blaney McMurtry summary)
So the outcome is clear, but the doctrine isn’t. Until the Court or the legislature settles it, counsel seeking to fix a probated will should plead both construction and rectification, and build the evidence to support either. Better still, raise a drafting error before the certificate of appointment issues. In Elizabeth Casey Cooke Family Trust v. Dioguardi, 2026 ONCA 85, which Kentros cites, the Court confirmed that the probate court can rectify a will before the certificate is issued, and treated a later negligence claim attacking the probated will as an abuse of process.
An executor can’t cash in on a drafting error
For me, this is the most practical lesson in the case.
Manthos wore two hats: surviving spouse and estate trustee. When the will turned out to have a gap, he resolved it in his own favour, took the properties without notice to the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (one grandchild was a minor), and moved them into a trust he controlled.
The application judge found that was a breach of fiduciary duty, and the Court of Appeal saw no error. The transfer to the alter ego trust was declared void and the properties went back to the estate, to be administered under the will as corrected.
The principle is simple. When a will is unclear about who’s entitled, the trustee’s job is to get the court’s direction, not to pick the reading that benefits them most.
Two smaller points worth knowing
Evidence about what the deceased said. Section 13 of Ontario’s Evidence Act prescribes that in a case by or against an estate, an opposite or interested party can’t win on their own uncorroborated evidence about anything that happened before the death, including conversations with the deceased. The appellant said Effie told him in 2015 she wanted him and his children to have one of the properties. The application judge didn’t accept it, and the Court of Appeal found no error, noting that corroboration can come from several pieces of independent evidence taken together. The Court also upheld reliance on admissions against interest by family members, and refused to let the appellant object on appeal to evidence he had put in himself or never objected to at the hearing.
Who pays. Because the litigation was caused by a flaw in the will, it was fair for the estate to bear part of the costs. But the estate didn’t have to pay for the share of costs caused by the parties’ own unreasonable positions. That’s consistent with the modern Ontario approach: estates pay for genuine problems the testator created, not for hard-nosed litigation.
What families and advisors should take from Kentros
Read your will before you sign it, especially the “what if” clauses. Life interests need a clear gift over for every scenario, not just the one where the spouse dies first.
A missing clause isn’t necessarily fatal. If the evidence of intention is clear, Ontario courts will try hard to avoid an intestacy. The drafting lawyer’s file and evidence can be decisive.
Executors must stay neutral when a will is unclear. Ask the court for directions. Taking estate assets on your own reading of an ambiguity can be undone, and can cost you personally.
Notify the Office of the Children’s Lawyer when minors have an interest. Skipping that step was part of what sank the trustee here.
Act early. Once property moves out of an estate, getting it back takes time and money, even when you win.
If you’re looking at a will that doesn’t say what your family member meant, or an executor who seems to be filling the gaps in their own favour, I’m glad to talk it through.
Kim
This post is general information, not legal advice. Every estate is different, so please get advice on your specific situation.
Here’s a scenario that keeps estate lawyers up at night: a will gives a spouse a life interest in property, names who takes if the spouse dies first, and then simply stops. Nobody wrote down who gets the property when the spouse’s life interest ends.
That’s exactly what happened in Kentros v. Kentros, 2026 ONCA 546, released by the Court of Appeal on July 28, 2026. The Court upheld orders giving effect to what the testator clearly meant and unwinding a trustee’s attempt to take advantage of the gap, and was candid that the law on fixing wills after probate is still unsettled in Ontario.
What happened
Effie Kentros died in March 2017. She left her husband, Manthos, and their children, including a daughter with two children, Matteo and Sofia.
Shortly before her death, Effie signed a new will dealing with two properties in Fort Erie. It gave Manthos a life interest in both. If Manthos didn’t survive her by 30 days, the properties went to the grandchildren. But Manthos did survive her, and the will said nothing about where the properties went after his life interest ended. The drafting lawyer later admitted he had simply left out the remainderman clause.
Manthos, who was also the estate trustee, obtained a certificate of appointment. In 2019 he moved both properties into an alter ego trust he had set up, where he kept the power to revoke the trust and to sell or mortgage the properties. His position was that, with no gift over, the properties fell into the residue, and the residue was his.
The application judge disagreed. He found clear evidence that Effie wanted the grandchildren to have the properties whenever Manthos died, and ordered language added to the will to say so. A family member appealed, and other parties cross-appealed on the choice of remedy and on costs. The Court of Appeal (Sossin, Gomery and Osborne JJ.A.) dismissed both.
Fixing a will after probate: construction or rectification?
This is the part of Kentros lawyers will be talking about.
Ontario draws a line between a court of probate, which decides what document is the will, and a court of construction, which decides what a probated will means. Because Manthos already had a certificate of appointment and nobody was attacking it, the application judge was sitting as a court of construction.
How far a court of construction can go in adding or deleting words is a genuinely open question here. Some Ontario cases allow it; others insist the court’s role is interpretive only. The Court of Appeal acknowledged that lingering uncertainty, and the criticism it has drawn, but didn’t need to resolve it.
Instead, the Court found it could reach the same result by construing the will as written, without adding words to it. The presumption against intestacy did a lot of work: nothing in the will suggested Effie meant to leave anything undisposed of, and the gift to the grandchildren if Manthos died first could fairly be read as her plan for when his interest ended. The missing clause was a clear drafting mistake, and correcting it simply let the will say what she meant. (All About Estates; Blaney McMurtry summary)
So the outcome is clear, but the doctrine isn’t. Until the Court or the legislature settles it, counsel seeking to fix a probated will should plead both construction and rectification, and build the evidence to support either. Better still, raise a drafting error before the certificate of appointment issues. In Elizabeth Casey Cooke Family Trust v. Dioguardi, 2026 ONCA 85, which Kentros cites, the Court confirmed that the probate court can rectify a will before the certificate is issued, and treated a later negligence claim attacking the probated will as an abuse of process.
An executor can’t cash in on a drafting error
For me, this is the most practical lesson in the case.
Manthos wore two hats: surviving spouse and estate trustee. When the will turned out to have a gap, he resolved it in his own favour, took the properties without notice to the Office of the Children’s Lawyer (one grandchild was a minor), and moved them into a trust he controlled.
The application judge found that was a breach of fiduciary duty, and the Court of Appeal saw no error. The transfer to the alter ego trust was declared void and the properties went back to the estate, to be administered under the will as corrected.
The principle is simple. When a will is unclear about who’s entitled, the trustee’s job is to get the court’s direction, not to pick the reading that benefits them most.
Two smaller points worth knowing
Evidence about what the deceased said. Section 13 of Ontario’s Evidence Act prescribes that in a case by or against an estate, an opposite or interested party can’t win on their own uncorroborated evidence about anything that happened before the death, including conversations with the deceased. The appellant said Effie told him in 2015 she wanted him and his children to have one of the properties. The application judge didn’t accept it, and the Court of Appeal found no error, noting that corroboration can come from several pieces of independent evidence taken together. The Court also upheld reliance on admissions against interest by family members, and refused to let the appellant object on appeal to evidence he had put in himself or never objected to at the hearing.
Who pays. Because the litigation was caused by a flaw in the will, it was fair for the estate to bear part of the costs. But the estate didn’t have to pay for the share of costs caused by the parties’ own unreasonable positions. That’s consistent with the modern Ontario approach: estates pay for genuine problems the testator created, not for hard-nosed litigation.
What families and advisors should take from Kentros
If you’re looking at a will that doesn’t say what your family member meant, or an executor who seems to be filling the gaps in their own favour, I’m glad to talk it through.
Kim
This post is general information, not legal advice. Every estate is different, so please get advice on your specific situation.